← View Full Feature Matrix: Adamant vs. VaultaireScore: 4.1 / 5
Vaultaire Review (2026): Strong Crypto Model, Slowed by Telemetry Defaults & Closed Source
Vaultaire deserves credit for bringing pattern-derived AES-256-GCM cryptography and candid threat-model writing to iOS. However, default-on PostHog/filename crash telemetry, closed-source crypto without KAT tests, device-wide Keychain salts, and lack of Clean Share or Calculator facade make Adamant a stronger choice for strict OpSec.
Strengths
- Pattern-derived PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA512 (600k rounds) + AES-256-GCM rather than weak PIN locks
- No account registration required and transparent writing about crypto boundaries
- Smooth iOS CloudKit sync and phrase-based shared vaults
Key Drawbacks & Tradeoffs
- PostHog analytics, crash diagnostics (potentially leaking filenames), Apple AdServices, and CloudKit backup are all ON by default
- Closed-source binary without published Known Answer Test verification vectors
- Missing Clean Share EXIF stripper, working Calculator facade, Ephemeral Browser, and auto-seeded Living Decoy
- Pricing is completely omitted from the main homepage and navigation bar
Summary Verdict
Best for: iOS users who prioritize automatic CloudKit sync over strict offline defaults, telemetry freedom, and built-in stealth utilities. If you want constant-size 16-slot pools, strict zero-telemetry defaults, Living Decoy auto-seeder, working Calculator Lock, and lower Lifetime pricing on iPhone & iPad, choose Adamant.